Friday, August 7, 2015

Great Self-Published Fantasy Blog-off - First Round Champion

Well, here we are, almost 5 months to the day, and 26 books later.

The first round of the Great Self-Published Fantasy Blog-off has been an interesting experience, and given me new-found appreciation for the job of an editor or agent. It really is a job and, as such, you go into it with a completely different approach than you might as a reader (or even as a reviewer). It's a volume business, with deadlines attached, and you're far more cognizant of the technical aspects because you're reading for a wider audience than just yourself.

Before I announce my First Round Champion, please allow me a moment to say a few words about my four finalists:

  • Sand of Bone by Blair MacGregor: The characters here were exceptionally strong and well-developed. The world building was a bit weak for me, but the social aspect of politics and family was well done. This was a violent, sometimes brutal read, but never without consequences.
  • Shattered Sands by William G Saraband: This distinguished itself from the first page. The characters were fantastic, full of both personality and surprises, and the world-building was solid, especially in terms of establishing a culture. If there’s any drawback, it’s that the story is so ugly and cruel that it makes for rather heavy reading at times.
  • Stormwalkers by K. Eric Mauser & Kevin Butterfield: This was a solid, thoroughly enjoyable read. It had an epic fantasy sense of scope, significant hints at greater world-building, and some very nice character development. Where the book floundered a bit for me was in its pacing, which is hard to ignore after such a stellar, raucous opening.
  • Dragon Fate by JD Hallowell: An all-round solid read, this was paced well, with great characters, an intriguing world, and a plot that flowed naturally from the opening scenes. If I were to have any complaints, it's that the dialogue felt a bit stilted and awkward at times, and that the actual plot development is more subtle than significant.

Selecting just one of these titles to be my Champion was tough. I put on that editor/agent hat, looked at each title from a commercial perspective, and tried to gauge which has the greatest success of embracing the widest possible audience.

That narrowed it down from two titles, from which I just had to go with my gut and trust my first impressions.

So, without further ado, my First Round Champion is . . .

Shattered Sands by William G Saraband



3 comments:

  1. Congrats to W G Saraband! I can't wait to read "Shattered Sands" during Round 2! I'm really looking forward to diving into what everyone else has declared the best of their batch! :D

    ReplyDelete
  2. Congratulations, William G. Saraband! Very well done. Good luck on round 2! This has been great fun and very educational.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you so much, Bob! Your words were very kind, I feel very humbled to have made it this far, it's so unbelievable! :)

    ReplyDelete